Validation in the MVC design pattern

Hello Martin,

your article on Notification implies that validation should be done in

the Model layer. There are numerous voices that see the need for

validation in the Controller, as it receives user input in the first

place. I argue that actually both should be done in Web applications:

– First you want to make sure that data integrity is given. You should

not outsource this essential task to the Controller or the View. If

integrity is not maintained by the database anyway, it MUST be done in

the model. An exception is an acceptable way to respond to invalid

data that is passed to the model.

– For usability reasons, you also want to have validation on the

controller level. This however should be mainly for usability reasons,

especially as the naming and number of model properties must not match

form fields in every case. In a form, an email address might be split

up in two input fields, whereas the model just uses one data field to

store the email address. The user expects feedback on whether the

username or domain part of the address are not valid. Also a modern

web form should be able to list multiple validation error at one

(which does not work that well when working with simple exceptions

that are thrown by models).

In (fat client) Rich Internet Applications, you might not just access

models in server-side controllers but you want to expose the model API

to your client side JavaScript models (which is then a web service).

If validation would be done in server-side controllers only, this

would lead to a security risk or you would need to create a controller

action per API function, which is basically repeated code.

Do you agree?

Merry Christmas and a happy new year,

Michael Mayer

Broadly yes. The domain model should be fundamentally responsible for validation, but presentations often need validation too. We need to support usability without introducing duplication.

For years now, I’ve been intending to capture and write about validation patterns. They are still on the horizon, although sadly distant.

Martin Fowler